A growing number of diners in major metropolitan areas are expressing concerns about the increasingly rigid and impersonal service at upscale restaurants. This trend, gaining traction since late 2023, is sparking debate about the future of fine dining and the balance between formality and genuine hospitality.
Background: A Shift in Dining Culture
For decades, fine dining has been associated with impeccable service – attentive, knowledgeable, and discreet. Restaurants like Per Se in New York City and The French Laundry in Yountville, California, set the standard for an elevated dining experience. This tradition emphasized a curated atmosphere, meticulous attention to detail, and staff trained to anticipate every need.
However, over the past few years, a noticeable shift has occurred. Some industry observers attribute this change to a combination of factors, including a staffing shortage exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and a growing emphasis on standardized, almost robotic, service protocols.
Key Developments: The Rise of “Slick” Service
Recent reports and online forums are filled with complaints describing service as overly formal, lacking warmth, and feeling scripted. Specifically, diners have noted an increase in rigid adherence to protocols, such as overly precise explanations of dishes, excessive use of formal language, and a perceived lack of genuine engagement.
One common complaint revolves around the removal of casual conversation. Instead of friendly banter, servers often deliver information in a detached manner, prioritizing adherence to a pre-determined script. The emphasis on presentation has also been criticized; while aesthetically pleasing, the focus on elaborate plating sometimes overshadows the dining experience itself.
Several high-profile restaurants have faced scrutiny. In early February 2024, a viral TikTok video featuring a patron at a Michelin-starred restaurant in Chicago sparked a wider conversation. The video depicted a server reciting the provenance of each ingredient with exhaustive detail, but without any personal touch or warmth, leading many viewers to label the experience as "stilted" and "uncomfortable."
Impact: Diners and the Restaurant Industry
The trend is impacting diners’ overall satisfaction with fine dining. Online review platforms like Yelp and OpenTable have seen a surge in negative reviews mentioning overly formal or impersonal service. Many diners express a desire for a more relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, where the focus is on enjoying the food and company.
The restaurant industry is also feeling the pressure. While some establishments are doubling down on formality, others are experimenting with a more approachable approach. Concerns are being raised about the potential for alienating customers and damaging the reputation of fine dining as a whole.
More Read
What Next: Adjustments and Re-evaluation
The industry is at a turning point, with many restaurants re-evaluating their service models. A growing number are prioritizing staff training that emphasizes empathy, genuine connection, and adapting service to individual diner preferences.
Potential Changes Being Considered
Empowering Staff: Giving servers more autonomy to deviate from scripts and respond to diner cues.
Focus on Connection: Encouraging servers to engage in brief, genuine conversations with guests.
Personalized Service: Tailoring recommendations and interactions based on diner preferences and dietary needs.
Training in Emotional Intelligence: Developing staff’s ability to read and respond to emotional cues.
It remains to be seen whether the fine dining industry can successfully navigate this shift and retain its appeal. However, the current trend suggests a growing demand for a more human-centered approach to upscale dining – one that balances formality with genuine hospitality.
